Table of Contents
Etsy, the global e-commerce platform known for unique and handmade goods, recently reported its highest-ever annual revenue of $2.7 billion in 2023. However, this figure masks deeper challenges facing the company.
For the second consecutive year, its gross merchandise sales—a measure of the total value of goods sold on the platform—declined.
In fact, Etsy’s stock has plummeted over 70% from its 2021 highs, and its first-quarter earnings results for 2024 did little to lift spirits.
Etsy Declining Sales Amidst Growing Revenue
While Etsy’s consolidated results were within guidance ranges, they fell short of expectations. Following a surge in buyers and spending during the COVID-19 pandemic, the company now finds itself at a standstill—essentially not growing for two years.
Longtime sellers have voiced their frustrations, partially blaming CEO Josh Silverman for prioritizing profits over the original mission of the platform.
Critics argue that this profit-driven focus has allowed counterfeit products and mass-produced items to flourish, diminishing the value for both artists and consumers.
One seller lamented, “Now I can’t compete… A lot of it [AI-generated art] is just junk.” This sentiment raises concerns about Etsy’s future direction, with some fearing it risks becoming “a slightly more expensive Amazon.”
The Shift from Artisan Focus to Profit Maximization
Founded in 2005 by Rob Kalin, Etsy was designed as a platform to empower artisans and connect them with buyers worldwide.
Initially, the platform thrived on a community-driven approach where sellers were pivotal in generating traffic and creating a vibrant marketplace.
However, after going public in 2015, the company faced increased pressure from shareholders focused on growth and profitability.
Following a series of leadership changes, including Silverman’s appointment in 2017, Etsy implemented various cost-cutting measures such as laying off 22% of its workforce and increasing transaction fees for sellers.
While these moves initially boosted sales and stock prices, they also sparked unrest among long-time users.
The Pandemic: A Double-Edged Sword
The pandemic was a turning point for Etsy; in April 2020, the platform sold an astounding $133 million worth of face masks—equating to 12 million individual items.
The number of active buyers surged by 77%, leading to a gross merchandise sales growth of over 100% year-over-year in 2020.
However, many industry analysts caution that this pandemic-related success may have been a temporary spike rather than a sustainable trend.
As discretionary spending declines in early 2024 and Etsy experienced lower-than-expected earnings results, concerns about the company’s long-term viability loom large.
In December 2023, Etsy laid off another 11% of its staff, further indicating an uncertain path ahead.
Etsy Seller Dissatisfaction and “Junk-ification”
Many sellers feel marginalized as Etsy changes how buyers interact with the platform. The recent focus has been on maximizing buyer engagement rather than enhancing individual seller experiences.
Chiarra Lohr, who leads the Indie Sellers Guild, expressed frustration over increasing fees and a controversial “star seller” program that prioritizes certain sellers based on metrics like fast shipping and high ratings.
Sellers claim that these changes have led to a “junk-ification” of Etsy’s offerings. The 2013 rule change allowing creators to outsource production has fueled this sentiment. Many sellers argue that their craft is being overshadowed by mass-produced goods and AI-generated designs.
Etsy Competition with E-Commerce Giants
Etsy faces fierce competition from e-commerce giants like Amazon and eBay, which invest significantly in marketing and have established repeat buyer bases.
As Etsy’s reputation deteriorates among its core community of artists and sellers, its leadership recognizes that adapting to market pressures is vital.
In response, Etsy has ramped up efforts to enhance compliance policies—reportedly removing 115% more listings for policy violations in early 2024 compared to the previous year. However, critics argue that these measures do not address the underlying issues affecting seller satisfaction.
What Lies Ahead for Etsy?
Etsy’s future hinges on its ability to balance profitability with its core values. With activist investor Elliott Management acquiring a 13% stake in the company in February 2024, there could be significant changes ahead.
Historically, activist investors have pushed for reforms that can positively impact companies like Etsy.
Some speculate that leveraging AI could enhance seller experiences rather than detract from them. However, many artists remain skeptical, yearning for direct relationships with their suppliers and collaborators instead of third-party interventions.
As Etsy grapples with its identity—balancing being a public company with its founding mission—many sellers feel trapped by a system that is increasingly difficult to navigate profitably.
Conclusion: A Call for Change
Etsy’s current trajectory raises important questions about its future direction. Can it remain true to its roots while adapting to market demands? Should it have pursued public status? While there are no easy answers, the company must confront these challenges swiftly if it hopes to retain its original community of artisans.
For more insights into Etsy’s performance and strategies moving forward, you can follow their official updates on Etsy’s Investor Relations.
Additionally, you can explore more about sustainable e-commerce practices through resources like B Corporation to understand how companies can balance profit with purpose.
Finally, if you’re interested in supporting local artisans or exploring unique handmade products, consider visiting Etsy directly—every purchase helps sustain creative small businesses.
